QuoteReplyTopic: A Deservedly Forgotten "Historic Moment"? Posted: August 23 2007 at 1:33am
NO ONE'S EVER ACCUSED RELIGIOUSLY INSPIRED MOVIES of BEING SUBTLE. BUT the GUNS-BLAZING, WOMEN-COWERING, MORMONS-GITTIN-UNJUSTLY-WHUPPED ACTION of SEPTEMBER DAWN MAY SET a NEW LOW for BEAT-'EM-OVER-the-HEAD DIDACTICISM. THE NASTIER REVIEWS HAVE COMPARED the FILM to HACK POLITICAL ADS and INFOMERCIALS SHILLING "MIRACLE CURE" DRUGS.
AMONG THOSE TRAPPED in THIS WELL- MEANING BUT LIFELESS EXERCISE: FORMER CLARK KENT DEAN CAIN, TERENCE STAMP as BRIGHAM YOUNG and 4-TIME RAZZIE® NOMINEE JON VOIGHT, as "THE LEADER of the PACK."
FEEL FREE to GIT OUT YER GUNZ an' SET 'EM a-BLAZING BELOW...
Here's my favorite line, from Nick Schager of Slant Magazine: "Forget Grindhouse. September Dawn is the year's first honest-to-goodness exploitation flick."
I don't know jack sh*t about the film, so I can't back my claim too much. But, whatever...
Obviously 2007, is a "Miss" stage in Jon Voight's hit or miss career as of late. ( Ali, The Five People you meet in Heaven, and the miniseries where he played the Pope were hits, Baby Geniuses 2, Pearl Harbor, and September Dawn are misses.) Although National Treasure 2 looks like it will be better than the first one.
Boy, Jon must really need the paychecks if he keeps doing all this trash in 2007 (Bratz, September Dawn) or he is trying break a record on how many movies that one actor can be in one year (I don't count Transformers or National Treasure 2 as part of his trash). Maybe he is just trying to throw us off.
P.S. Still have no idea what this film is about or what is so Historical???
The "Networking IT" Movie Buff!
Words to live by: "Money doesn't make you happy. I now have $50 million but I was just as happy when I had $48 million." - Arnold Schwarzenegger
The last couple of times I've seen Jon Voight, I have been left to wonder if it is really him, or if they were just using the wax statue of him that used to reside in The Movieland Wax Museum (now defunct).
Here is a website (with a bunch of links) if anyone's interested in the back story that inspired this movie. Personally, I already live too close to Utah!
I have yet to see this film, but I've read some of the reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, and my reactions are based on those.
I don't know of any GOOD movies about any point in Mormon history, not even of the lives of Joseph Smith or Brigham Young, let alone the dark, "we don't want to talk about this" points in their history, those points which every religion I've read about has. If HeadRAZZBerry or others could name a few of those movies, I'd appreciate it. I'd love to see a GOOD movie about gunslinger/U.S. Marshal/Joseph Smith bodyguard Orrin Porter Rockwell (he's a wonderful character, but there's only one apparently poor movie about him). I'd also like one about the voyage of the Brooklyn with its 200 plus Mormons who decided to leave the United States for California only to take a detour to the Sandwich Islands (a.k.a. Hawaii) and when they finally arrived in California, it's now part of the U.S. (but the movie must honestly deal with the widow Lucy Buell Eagar (I'm not making up her name) and the three men, all of which newspaperman Captain Brannan excommunicated for bad doctrine and immorality--seeing the daily ship schedule, I want to know where they found the time!) as well as the rest of them, who the non-Mormons claim were the epitome of virtue.
That said, it shouldn't be hard to do a well done, sad but historical movie about the Mountain Meadows Massacre. It's easy to bash the Mormon church about this incident because they covered it up, but I could point to other incidents other religions, Christian or otherwise, have covered up, too. A movie about this incident should show it all, the paranoia between Mormons and non-Mormons at this time, the ill-fated Baker-Fancher party in yet another case of being in the wrong place at the wrong time, the build-up of bizarre logic used to justify the massacre and the heartbreak of Haight when he received, well too late, the notice from Brigham Young to let them through. A few paragraphs at the end can mention the cover-up until recent times. But just let the movie tell the story; don't moralize over it.
Last year we had an excellent film called Blood Diamonds. The makers of that film could have moralized about how wrong everything was until they were blue in the face. If they did, they would have failed to make their case. Instead, they showed the brutality and the humanity. The conclusion was inescapable, but they NEVER HIT YOU OVER THE HEAD WITH IT. They put it all out there and let you decide.
Talking about horrible events with religious overtones may be trickier, but it seems to me the same approach should be taken.
And please don't saddle it with the "star-crossed lovers" storyline.
Wow, Jon Voight is a definite contender for WORST SUPPORTING ACTOR. He was in "Transformers", "Bratz", and now this movie. No wonder Angelina doesn't speak to him!
Angelina, however, has been targeted by the Razzies for quite a while, though she was missed out for 2 straight years. All that was from 2001-2004, 5 times she's been nominated, and yet she hasn't even "won" a Razzie. A 4-time Worst Actress Razzie nominee for 7 films, Lara Croft: Tomb Raider and Original Sin (2001), Life or Something Like It (2002), Beyond Borders and Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (2003) and Alexander and Taking Lives (2004). She's also been nominated for Worst Razzie Loser of Our First 25 Years in 2004, but lost that award to Ah-Nuld Schwarzenegger.
However, I feel Angelina Jolie has made great recent strides to redeeming her career with such films as The Good Shepherd and A Mighty Heart, and I enjoyed Mr. & Mrs. Smith and look forward to Beowulf.
Her father, on the other hand, continues to lend his great talents to substandard fare. For example, I felt Jon Voight did a fine job portraying the Secretary of Defense in Transformers. Made me wish he really was the Secretary of Defense. But what was he doing in Transformers?
And, if the reviews are correct, what is he doing in as awful a piece of dreck as September Dawn?
I hope father will follow his daughter's lead (and find good roles offered to him, too).
Angelina, however, has been targeted by the Razzies for quite a while, though she was missed out for 2 straight years. All that was from 2001-2004, 5 times she's been nominated, and yet she hasn't even "won" a Razzie. A 4-time Worst Actress Razzie nominee for 7 films, Lara Croft: Tomb Raider and Original Sin (2001), Life or Something Like It (2002), Beyond Borders and Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (2003) and Alexander and Taking Lives (2004). She's also been nominated for Worst Razzie Loser of Our First 25 Years in 2004, but lost that award to Ah-Nuld Schwarzenegger.
Isn't it weird how they've both got Academy Awards and razzie nominations? Like Father Like Daughter.
Jabba thuh Putz is brilliant. Also, Scott Holleran liked "Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle", the second worst sequel of all time (after "Batman & Robin", of course), and hated "Pan's Labrynth" and "Thank You For Smoking". I see what you mean.
Joel Schumacher is history's greatest monster!-Robot Chicken https://twitter.com/SchumacherH8r Next-up: The Oogieloves
I think Jon Voight and Christopher Walken are in a contest to see who can make the worst batch of movies this year while playing strange characters. I'd say it's a match between two of their movies, "Bratz" (Voight and his fake noise) and "Balls of Fury" (Walken with his weird clothes and hair).
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum